Catholic Public Domain Version
Exodus 18:17
“But he said, "This is not good, what you are doing.”
Verse Explanation
A saved explanation for Exodus 18:17.
Plain-language explanation
Moses is being urged to judge wisely, and then he responds that the current way of doing things is not good. The point is that the approach being taken needs to be corrected so it can serve people better and be fair.
Catholic context
Many Catholics understand this exchange as a lesson in responsible leadership. Good governance—especially in matters of justice—requires order, wisdom, and restraint. It also highlights the importance of hearing counsel and adjusting one’s plans for the common good.
Historical background
This takes place during Israel’s journey after the Exodus. Moses was overwhelmed with disputes and requests for judgment. Jethro’s advice (in the surrounding passage) leads to a more structured system of help, so the people can receive fair decisions without exhausting the leader.
Reflection
When something “is not good,” it doesn’t always mean the goal is wrong—it may mean the method needs correction. This verse invites us to be honest about what isn’t working and open to wise counsel.
Practical takeaway
If a task, role, or plan isn’t producing good outcomes, pause and ask: What needs to be changed? Seek wise advice from those qualified, and adjust the process so justice, patience, and order are better served.
Prayer
Lord, give us wisdom to recognize what needs correction and courage to follow good counsel. Help us lead with fairness and care, so our decisions serve Your people. Guide our hearts toward what is truly good. Amen.