Catholic Public Domain Version
Genesis 37:20
“Come, let us kill him and cast him into the old cistern. And let us say: 'an evil wild beast has devoured him.' And then it will become apparent what his dreams will do for him."”
Verse Explanation
A saved explanation for Genesis 37:20.
Plain-language explanation
Joseph’s brothers speak cruelly about him. They suggest murdering him and throwing his body into a cistern, then inventing a story to cover their wrongdoing (“an evil wild beast”). Their aim is to stop his future from unfolding—especially the meaning they think is tied to his dreams.
Catholic context
Catholics often read Genesis as showing how sin grows when people harden their hearts. Even though Joseph’s brothers act in betrayal, God remains faithful and can bring good out of evil. This verse also highlights the way lies can be used to disguise wrongdoing, something the Church consistently urges us to avoid.
Historical background
In the family life of the ancient world, siblings had strong social bonds—and also real tensions. A “cistern” was a storage pit for water; throwing someone into it could effectively mean death. The brothers also plan a cover story so others won’t suspect them. Their “dreams” echo the earlier theme in Genesis that Joseph’s dreams carry meaning, which these brothers resent.
Reflection
It’s sobering to see how quickly cruelty can become “plan-making.” Their speech is not a moment of anger only—it’s deliberate plotting. This passage invites us to watch for the thoughts we entertain, the words we justify, and the stories we might tell to excuse wrongdoing.
Practical takeaway
When you feel tempted to retaliate or hide wrong motives, pause. Ask: “Am I justifying harm or spinning a lie?” Choose honesty, and if needed, seek help early (a trusted person, prayer, or confession) rather than letting anger become a plan.
Prayer
Lord God, give us clean hearts and truthful lips. Deliver us from the temptation to harm others or to cover sin with excuses. Teach us to trust your providence and to choose mercy over cruelty, especially when we feel wronged. Through Christ our Lord. Amen.